Fantasy Drawings and Their Significance in Criminal Investigative Analysis
©2008 Vernon J. Geberth
Practical Homicide Investigation
Reprint: Law and Order, Vol. 56, No. 10, October, 2008
Article Expanded for Research
Return to Research Materials
All human sexual activities are initiated through fantasies, which are mental images usually involving some fulfilled or unfulfilled desire. Fantasy plays a major role in everyone's sexual behavior. It is the drive factor for sexual expression. Sexual fantasies normally consist of imaginations and/or a series of mental images that are sexually stimulating. The contrast of these "normal" fantasies would be the aberrant development of bizarre mental images involving grotesque unnatural distortions of sexual imagery as depicted in sexually sadistic pornography.
There is no doubt in my mind, based on years of investigative analysis of sadistic sex crimes and the criminals who perpetrate these events, that sexually sadistic pornography is directly linked to sadistic sex crimes. The author has investigated, supervised, consulted on, assessed and researched numerous cases in which photographs, drawings, video tapes, books, pornography in men's magazines, women's lingerie and clothing along with anatomically correct dolls were recovered in the homes of sexual offenders and/or persons who died as a result of autoerotic fatalities to stimulate themselves.
The Sexual Offender
A person who is aroused with thoughts and fantasies of sexual aggression oftentimes incorporates elements into his life that serve to enhance his violent fantasies. An offender can also live out his sexual fantasies through fantasy drawings, which serve as a form of rehearsal before actually committing the offense. The fantasy drawings may be based on a mind picture referred to as an "engram," which is conjured up in the imagination and/or fantasy. Or, the fantasy drawings may be predicated on a mental re-creation of an actual event. In that case, the fantasy drawings become actual evidence against the offender.
In The BTK serial murder case, the offender Dennis Rader was convicted of killing ten victims over an extended period of time, one of the issues confounding law enforcement was BTK's ability to stop killing for prolonged periods of time and then resume his killing. This dynamic just didn't fit the accepted protocol of serial killers. It was only after his arrest and subsequent confessions that authorities learned why he had these "gaps' in the murder events.
Dennis Rader told the authorities that he would use his fantasy drawings and pictures of his victims to sexually stimulate himself in order to relive the murders.
These fantasy drawings became significant in corroborating his statements and the evidence recovered from the execution of the numerous search warrants linking BTK to each of the murders.
The author also has numerous cases of offender's acting-out sadistic fantasies based on violent pornography as well as their own drawings and paintings depicting sexual assault.
In fact, empirical studies indicate that many sex offenders reported having masturbatory fantasies before acts of sexual aggression and that the content of the fantasy was similar to the nature of their sexual offense. (Glueck, 1956 and McGuire, Carlisle and Young, 1965)
In the author's opinion many sexual assaults and/or homicides are a direct result of an offender acting out a specific sexual fantasy fueled by sadistic pornography.
Criminal Investigative Analysis
The applications of clinical criteria and abnormal psychology to the investigative process are an integral part of criminal personality profiling and have been universally recognized and accepted as genuine and legitimate investigative techniques. Detectives and criminal investigators routinely employ these techniques in their investigation of violent crime on a case-by-case basis. From a practical standpoint, there are only so many ways to kill and only so many stories to tell as an offender attempts to explain the killings. After a while a distinct pattern emerges, which encompass a series of clusters of behavioral information and specific typologies of offenders
Criminal investigative analysis is a process of reviewing crimes from both a behavioral and investigative perspective. It involves reviewing and assessing the facts of a criminal act, interpreting offender behavior, and interaction with the victim, as exhibited during the commission of the crime, or as displayed in the crime scene.
Clinically speaking, there is a behavioral distinctiveness in human sexuality. This unique aspect of our sexual arousal and response system accounts for why individuals differ in their sexual behaviors and engage in a specific series of behavioral patterns. In sex-related criminal incidents the offender is oftentimes subconsciously "acting-out" a sexually significant behavioral pattern, which reflects the underlying personality, lifestyle, and developmental experiences of the offender. Fantasy Drawings provide a unique insight into the mind of the offender, whose love for detail and sexual expression inadvertently provides the investigator with the offenders' innermost sexual thought processes and fantasies. Not to mention evidence. When you have the inner most thoughts of an offender, written or drawn by his own hand, there are no better "data" from which to draw conclusions about a particular offender and his sexual activities.
The investigative goal is to interpret these actions and behaviors of offender and then translate these psychodynamics into investigative reality.
Fantasy Drawings As An Investigative Roadmap
Fantasy is the drive factor for sexual expression and plays a major role in everyone's sexual behavior. However, for the sexual offender, fantasy becomes the paramount stimulus expressed through sexual aggression, domination, power and control. These individuals are aroused with thoughts and fantasies of sexual aggression, which they reinforce through repetition illustrated by the use of sadistic pornography and their fantasy drawings. The accumulation of materials, including "rape and/or murder" kits that the offender used to control his victims and enhance his sexual fantasies as well as implements he used to sexually torture his victims become an integral part of the fantasy drawings as he attempts recreate the actual event in the fantasy drawing in order to relive the experience through fantasy. These drawings can be introduced into evidence as an example of the role of fantasy.
Fantasy drawings, pornography, writings and journals, sexual devices and toys, lingerie, bondage devices, scripted drawings and/or photos depicting a specific fantasy, are all very significant in any investigative analysis. In fact, based on my personal experience and dealings with sexual offenders and their insatiable appetite for sexual stimuli I can guarantee that within their collection of these materials is the specific roadmap of their offense.
Many pedophiles have been able to circumvent the laws on child pornography through fantasy drawings and sexually explicit cartoon. There are Websites, which feature sexually sadistic pornographic drawings of children involved with adults to satisfy pedophile fantasy. The website drawings have been rendered as "simulations" to avoid child pornography laws.
Their advertising states, "Only 3D toon can satisfy because CARTOONS have no Limits, no Borders, no Rules. Examples are: http:/www.sin3dincest.com and http:/leejoy.info. Cartoon type drawings can sexually arouse individuals who are predisposed to the subject matter and these fantasies will tend to "linger." Many of these cartoon drawings are created in 3D format thereby providing a realistic impact. This would certainly be significant in a criminal investigative analysis of persons suspected in a child pornography case, who were in possession of these materials along with the fantasy drawings.
In a Law and Order article I wrote in November 2000 I presented the reader with a unique case of Domestic Violence Lust Murder in which the offender had sexually mutilated his wife during a domestic argument. The offender had sketched and painted hundreds of fantasy drawings of nude women being shot and stabbed into their breasts. The violence increased in various drawings and had even been scripted to fit his fantasies of women as whores who had to be punished and killed. The constant theme that Frank scripted was one of sexual sadism with the infliction of pain and suffering on his models accompanied with their scripted pleas.
In my opinion when someone begins to script his fantasy drawings they have become "vested" in the fantasy and have effectively created an engram, which allows them to reinforce a specific sexual fantasy. Furthermore, if an individual has vested in sexually sadistic fantasies the fantasy drawings and scripts merge into an insidious relationship in which fantasy and reality become integrated into their everyday lives. The significance of these particular fantasy drawings was that the wounds on his wife's body as well as the knife protruding from her chest bore an eerie resemblance to the drawings and paintings that the detectives recovered in the home.
In the reconstruction and analysis of this homicide it was determined that there had been some sort of sexual confrontation between the husband and wife during a domestic argument. The husband was discovered nude from the waist down with blood on his legs and genitals. His wife had been stripped of her clothing and had extensive and multiple stab wounds into her chest, breasts and genitalia. The husband's rage and anger escalated during which time he became "out-of-control"
This acute psychotic reaction would clinically be described as a temporary break from reality. During this break the husband acted out his most primal and perverse sadistic fantasies. These actions were apparently predicated upon a perverse fantasy system fueled by his involvement with his drawings and his sadistic pornography and reinforced by the scripted fantasy stories depicting sexual sadism.
A Prototypical Case Involving Fantasy Drawings
An individual whom I consider to be the most evil criminal sexual sadist I have ever researched illustrated the dynamics of this phenomenon in his fantasy drawings, which he used to recreate his sexual tortures and sexually stimulate his sexual fantasies.
In one of his drawings he had depicted a gagged female victim, who was in restraints with her arms tied behind her back and her wrists tightly bound. You could actually see the marks from a whipping. Her ankles were bound and secured to the floor and a pole. Her breasts had been wrapped and bound with straps and her nipples had been pierced and tied to a knee restraint, which secured her to a pole. There was a small dildo in her anal cavity secured by a strap, which was part of a harness attached to her hips. The drawing showed the victim being penetrated by another larger dildo with spikes attached to a pole secured into the floor. There were various sexual implements displayed within the drawing, such as handcuffs, ropes and straps as well as eyelets secured into the wall for victim restraint. In addition, the offender had sketched an electric cattle prodder hanging on the wall behind her and an electrical charge box with wires and electrodes plugged into the wall. The offender also drew various size dildos, which appeared on the floor along with a bottle of petroleum jelly.
Is this a Sexual Fantasy or Reality?
This was one of hundreds of drawings that were recovered during a search of the offender's compound. What makes this as well as his other drawings so significant is that they actually portray what the offender was doing to his victims as he sexually assaulted and tortured them. The various objects drawn into the picture, (dildos, electric cattle prodder, electric charger box, wires, restraints, leather straps, petroleum jelly and torture tools), were in fact recovered by the authorities during the crime scene search. Needless to say, these fantasy drawings became an essential portion of the prosecution's case especially when defense experts tried to portray the drawings as harmless sexual fantasies.
Law Enforcement Considerations
The first step is to understand the role of fantasy in sex-related homicide and death investigations. Collect and preserve physical as well as psychological evidence in sex-related death investigations. Determine the M.O. and signature characteristics at crime scenes committed by sex murderers. Understand the follow-up and investigative procedures involved in rape, sodomy, lust murder and serial murder investigations.
Detectives involved in the investigation of sex-related homicides and deaths should be aware of the role of fantasy. Fantasy fuels the mental and emotional processes underlying human behavior revealed in the crime scene or accidental death event. Fantasy also serves as an indication of the "signature" of an offender, which enables detectives to link an offender to a particular series of crimes committed by that offender.
Sexual sadists rely heavily on fantasy and ritual to obtain sexual satisfaction. There is an element of compulsivity as well as an obsession on the part of the sexual sadist to keep trophies and recordings of the event. Photographs of the victims played a significant part in their rituals as well as their ability to recall their sadistic acts.
Therefore, the author recommends that any search warrant applications in these type cases should certainly reference fantasy drawings, photographs as well as any records, scripts, letters, maps, diaries, audiotapes, videotapes, and newspaper reports of the crimes as possible evidence to be seized.
Vernon J. Geberth, M.S., M.P.S. author of the Practical Homicide Investigation: Tactics, Procedures, and Forensic Techniques, FOURTH EDITION and Sex-Related Homicide and Death Investigation: Practical and Clinical Perspectives CRC Press, LLC. These materials are excerpted with Geberth's permission and are protected under U.S. Copyright Laws.
Return to Top Return to Research Materials
"We work for God."®